10 Best Pie Shops In NYC To Order From This Thanksgiving Season (2024)

Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and if you’re getting ready to plan your Thanksgiving dinner, you can’t forget about the pie! This dessert is an absolute must on any dinner table, and here in NYC you can get some of the best. Whether you love apple pie…or fancy your chances with some pecan pie, there lots of bakeries and shops around the city to order from! Here are some of the best pie shops in NYC we recommend placing your order at!

1. Petee’s Pie Company, Lower East Side & Clinton Hill

There’s a reason Petee’s Pie Company is regarded as the “absolute best pie in NYC” and it’s because of their offerings like the Pumpkin Pie, Hudson Valley Apple Pie, Brown Butter Honey Pecan Pie, and so much more.

Both full size and 6″ options are available to preorder until November 19, and then the rest will be available on first-come first-served basis. Delivery is also available on 11/20 and 11/21! Learn more and place order here.

Where:

Lower East Side – 61 Delancey St

Clinton Hill – 505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn

2. Breads Bakery, Multiple Locations

Breads Bakery is one of our favorite bakeries in NYC, and this Thanksgiving season they’re serving up goodies like a classic Pumpkin Pie, Apple Crumb Pie, Pecan Tart Pie, and Babka Pie. Is your mouth watering yet?! What about the exclusive vegan Blueberry Pie which is only available for preorder?

You can preorder your desserts now if you wish through their website, or pick one up at an NYC location starting November 10! Learn more and order here.

Where: Find your location here

3. Maman, Multiple Locations

NYC’s beloved French bakery and café Maman is whipping up local pies this holiday season, and you can preorder them now! Select favorites include the Classic Pecan Pie (crunchy pecans & a sweet filling in a flaky pie crust), Pumpkin Pie with Whipped Mascarpone Cream Cheese (pumpkin filling, warm spices and topped with mascarpone cream cheese in a flaky pie crust), and Spiced Apple Crumb Pie (classic apple pie made with fresh apples, spices & topped with a cinnamon oat crumble).

You can choose between 9″ pies (serve 8-10) for $42 or individual pies (serves 1) for $6! You can pick it up from 11/15 – 11/23, or have it delivered if the total order is over $150. Learn more and place order here.

Where: Find your location here

4. Pies ‘n’ Thighs, Williamsburg

Even though it’s right in the name…the pies at Pies ‘n’ Thighs are the real deal! Although we love their fried chicken which is equally as great, we’re here for the Southern homestyle desserts. We’re talking the classics like Pumpkin Pie and Apple Pie…but also some of their signature items like the Sour Cherry Pear Crumble Pie and Banana Cream Pie. You can preorder your dessert for Thanksgiving Day pickup here!

Where: 166 S 4th St, Brooklyn

5. Bubby’s, Tribeca

Bubby’s is making it easy this holiday season by offering up their Bubby’s Thanksgiving Meal at Home, a ready-to-eat take-out package that includes all sorts of essentials for $200. Or, you can snag one of their homemade pies ($50) in flavors like pumpkin with caramel and pecan pralines, double crust apple, Michigan sour cherry, pecan maple and more.

Orders can be placed by Nov 16 with pick up on Nov 20-22! Learn more and place order here.

Where: 120 Hudson St

6. Four & Twenty Blackbirds, Park Slope

This women-owned bakery in Brooklyn proudly serves pies with the freshest ingredients sourced from local orchards! These one-of-a-kind pies you won’t find anywhere else (we promise)…like the Brown Butter Apple Streusel (blend of locally grown sweet and tart apples, with warm notes of vanilla and nutty browned butter, topped with signature buttery streusel) and the signature Salty Honey®. See all pie options and order here.

Where: 439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn

7. The Little Pie Company, Hell’s Kitchen

Little Pie Company is an NYC institution and their Thanksgiving menu is impressing this year! Their homemade pies (which serve 8-10) will cost you $42 apiece, ranging from traditional apple and pumpkin pies to other variations like the Mississippi Mud Pie, Three Berry Pie, and Southern Pecan Pie. Preorders are up now and you can pick up Thanksgiving week! See their full menu and order here.

Where: 424 W 43rd St

8. Dominique Ansel Bakery, SoHo

We know that Dominique Ansel Bakery is famous for their cronut…but this Thanksgiving it’s all about the pies! Choose between the Salted Caramel Apple Pie or Bourbon Pecan Pie, you won’t regret it. You can have it delivered from Nov 8-22! Learn more and order here.

Where: 189 Spring St

9. Abu’s Homestyle Bakery, Bed-Stuy

Abu’s Homestyle Bakery is a family-owned operation that fuses traditional recipes with modern design! Their pie options are short and sweet…and stray away from the ordinary Thanksgiving flavors. We’re talking the signature Bean Pie, as well as the Sweet Potato Pie, Pecan Pie, and Coconut Custard Pie (our personal favorite). Order your pie here.

Where: 1184 Fulton St, Brooklyn

10. The Bakery at Greywind, Hudson Yards

This cute all-day bakery in Hudson Yards sits next to its parent restaurant Greywind, and is selling Turkey Pot Pies with Apple Cider Gravy and Thyme this Thanksgiving! These 9″ pies serve 6-8 people and will cost $78 a piece! You can preorder your pie by emailing hello@greywindnyc.com and scheduling a pickup on 11/22 or 11/23 from 8 am – 3 pm.

Where: 451 10th Ave Entrance, W 35th St